What Happened?
If you hike or live around San Francisco Bay, a House bill would start a federal study of whether the approximately 550-mile Bay Area Ridge Trail should become a national scenic trail. The House Natural Resources Committee reported the Bay Area Ridge Trail study bill Oct. 29, and it now sits on the Union Calendar, the House list of bills awaiting floor action, according to a Legis1 review of the bill's history and committee report.
Here is what the bill does:
- Federal study: It changes the National Trails System Act to direct the Secretary of the Interior to study whether the trail qualifies.
- Three-year limit: The study would have to be finished within three years of the bill becoming law.
- No designation: The bill does not make the trail a national scenic trail.
Why Does it Matter to Me?
The trail is owned and managed by 40 different land-managing partners, Janet McBride, executive director of the Bay Area Ridge Trail Council, told a House subcommittee. She said national scenic trail status "wouldn't change any of that at all."
Rep. Jared Huffman (D-CA) introduced the bill Jan. 27 with 11 original cosponsors, all California Democrats. The full committee ordered it reported by unanimous consent Sept. 15, after a July 1 hearing on seven bills.
Both Sides, Now
Supporters, including McBride, say national scenic trail status would not hand ownership or management to the federal government. Rep. Mike Thompson (D-CA) called the bill a critical first step toward designation. Rep. Mark DeSaulnier (D-CA) said he joined the Bay Area delegation in introducing legislation to designate the trail.
Opponents point to cost and upkeep. At the hearing, Rep. Emily Randall (D-WA) said a primary concern about new federal designations is "the potential long-term fiscal and management burden placed on the federal government." She noted that the Trump administration testified against studying more national trail designations because it was prioritizing deferred maintenance on existing federal lands.
That maintenance backlog is documented. The Congressional Research Service, Congress's in-house research arm, estimated deferred maintenance across four federal land agencies at $35.53 billion for fiscal year 2022. The U.S. Forest Service put its own estimate at over $8.6 billion for fiscal year 2023.
Congress is the body that acts here. The House must vote on the bill, and Sen. Adam Schiff (D-CA) has backed the effort.
What Happens Next?
No House floor vote has been scheduled. Schiff's office announced that the Senate unanimously passed its version of the legislation.
If the study is completed, any later designation of the trail would need a separate act of Congress.
---
AllCiv makes it easy to stay politically informed and involved.
---
Spot something wrong? Report an issue with this article