What Happened?

If you work for the federal government, a message from your agency that crosses into partisan politics can bring penalties under the Hatch Act. Federal law limits partisan political messaging by agencies, and a Legis1 review of a Congressional Research Service (CRS) report, published Monday, found the line depends on the facts of each case. ​

The Hatch Act, which restricts federal employees' political activity and was first enacted in 1939, covers nearly all civilian executive branch employees but exempts the president and vice president. Annual appropriations provisions also ban "publicity or propaganda," meaning purely partisan messages paid for by taxpayers.

Messages that discuss, promote, or defend an administration's policy generally do not violate the Hatch Act, the report said. Campaign-related activity does. The Office of Special Counsel (OSC) weighs four factors:

  • Purpose: Whether the message had a clear, contemporaneous non-electoral purpose.
  • Timing: How close the message came to an election.
  • Tone: Whether the message was neutral or attacked a party.
  • Context: How the message was spread.

Why Does it Matter to Me?

The penalties fall on individual workers. The Merit Systems Protection Board can order removal, a reduction in grade, suspension, reprimand, civil fines, or a ban from federal employment for up to five years.

Taxpayer money is also involved. Breaking the propaganda ban can violate the Antideficiency Act, which requires agencies to report violations to the president and Congress.

OSC treats a message that works as a "closing argument" for a candidate as potentially prohibited. It cited a Cabinet secretary's op-ed, published the day before a presidential election, that focused almost entirely on the incumbent candidate's accomplishments.

Both Sides, Now

The report said defending the Trump administration's policies is generally allowed. OSC has advised that "neutrally framed" references to a political party in an ongoing dispute are unlikely to be prohibited, while ones "gratuitous, made close to an election, and framed as an attack on a party" are more likely to be.

On Sept. 25, OSC announced that discipline was not warranted over partisan messages during the 2025 shutdown, because employees had reasonably relied on its earlier guidance.

The Campaign Legal Center announced that a federal court on Oct. 11 blocked taxpayer-funded partisan political advertisements for 14 days.

The Government Accountability Office (GAO) has said a violation requires an agency justification "so palpably erroneous as to be unreasonable," in a decision.

What Happens Next?

With no bright-line rule, a disputed message is judged on its own timing, tone, purpose, and context.

OSC "can neither enforce its own subpoenas nor compel agencies to respond to its investigative requests," the report said. It also cannot start disciplinary proceedings against certain high-level officials, which limits its reach over an agency head responsible for partisan messaging.

---

AllCiv makes it easy to stay politically informed and involved.

---

Spot something wrong? Report an issue with this article