What Happened?

If you live on tribal land in the U.S., only your state can start the process of moving criminal cases there back under federal authority. A tribe can’t ask for that change on its own, and a state can make it without the tribe’s consent, a Government Accountability Office report released Monday, Nov. 16, found. ​

The rules come from Public Law 280, a 1953 law that took most federal criminal authority over Indian country in certain states and handed it to those states. Handing it back is called retrocession. The Government Accountability Office (GAO) said shutting tribes out of that decision impedes their right to govern themselves, according to a Legis1 review of the report.

Why Does it Matter to Me?

About 65% of the 575 federally recognized tribes are in states named in the law. In those states, tribes generally share criminal authority with the state when a tribal citizen commits a crime or, in some cases, is the victim, and earlier research GAO cited ties the setup to slow police response times and less access to some federal money.

The money gap is wide. Bureau of Indian Affairs (BIA) spending on police, courts and jails for tribes in the five lower-48 states the law covered from the start totaled about $152 million from fiscal 2017 through 2021, roughly 5% of the $2.8 billion the bureau estimated they needed, while tribes in other lower-48 states got about $1.9 billion, or 21% of their estimated need, according to a February GAO report. BIA officials told GAO they have little discretionary money and generally put tribes that get no state services first.

Both Sides, Now

Sen. Lisa Murkowski (R-AK), who now chairs the Senate Committee on Indian Affairs, requested the study in 2023 with Sen. Alex Padilla (D-CA), Sen. Jeff Merkley (D-OR) and Rep. Jared Huffman (D-CA). “It’s time we take a serious look at this law and rectify the damage it has caused to tribal communities,” Huffman said in a 2023 statement, and tribal leaders told GAO that retrocession helped their tribes govern themselves and eased problems working with state police.

State law enforcement officials see a cost. They told GAO that retrocession can be a challenge because tribes would lose access to state public safety and justice services. Some tribes and local agencies have instead signed cross-deputization agreements, which give tribal officers powers similar to local police.

What Happens Next?

GAO made no recommendations to federal agencies. Instead, it asked Congress to consider two changes to the law, and it lists both as open:

  • Tribes start: Let tribes begin retrocession, and make federal criminal authority exclusive once the Interior secretary accepts it.
  • Tribes consent: Require a tribe’s consent before a state offers retrocession to the Interior secretary.

Some states have acted on their own. A 2025 Oregon law lets tribes formally ask the governor to start retrocession and sets deadlines for a response, InvestigateWest reported.

---

AllCiv makes it easy to stay politically informed and involved.

---

Spot something wrong? Report an issue with this article