What Happened?

If you walk, bike or drive on local streets, the traffic control standards behind the signs, signals and pavement markings you see are ones engineers almost never change, even where the rules allow it. Almost all the traffic engineers and other practitioners interviewed said they have never or rarely deviated, according to a Legis1 review of the U.S. Government Accountability Office (GAO) report Traffic Control Devices Manual: Selected Practitioners Reported Never or Rarely Deviating from DOT Standards. ​

The Federal Highway Administration (FHWA) issues the *Manual on Uniform Traffic Control Devices for Streets and Highways*, which sets national criteria for signs, signals and pavement markings. FHWA permits deviations under certain conditions, including to protect vulnerable road users such as pedestrians and cyclists.

Some practitioners did report deviating occasionally. Their reasons:

  • Saving money: Several said they departed from the Manual to cut costs.
  • Local problems: Several said they did so to address local issues affecting efficiency or safety.

Why Does it Matter to Me?

If you cross a street on foot or by bike, the 11th Edition (2023) of the Manual includes new devices meant to enhance safety for vulnerable road users. Almost all practitioners GAO interviewed view the Manual as the authoritative source of standards and guidance.

GAO says many traffic engineers were reluctant to deviate because they could face a lawsuit if a crash happened at the site of the change.

FHWA also keeps a public online database tracking requests for experiments, interpretations and changes to the Manual. GAO says the database gives few details on experiments or change requests; GAO says clearer access to those details could help practitioners test devices on the roads they operate.

Both Sides, Now

Many practitioners say deviations risk detracting from uniformity, which GAO says reduces confusion for road users. Safety organizations, GAO says, have expressed concern that engineers may be unwilling to deviate even when doing so might make roadways safer for vulnerable road users.

FHWA writes and revises the Manual, weighing practitioner feedback, including change requests and successful experiments. FHWA told GAO it has the detailed experiment information and gives it to practitioners on request. GAO says that option is not clearly stated on FHWA's website, and many practitioners are unaware of it.

What Happens Next?

GAO made one recommendation to the Department of Transportation (DOT). The Secretary of Transportation should ensure the FHWA Administrator prominently displays, on the Manual's website, contact information and clear instructions for getting more detailed information on experiments listed in the Official Rulings database. DOT agreed.

GAO lists the recommendation as open, meaning actions to satisfy its intent have not been taken or are being planned. GAO says it will provide updated information when it confirms what actions the agency has taken.

---

AllCiv makes it easy to stay politically informed and involved.

---

Spot something wrong? Report an issue with this article