What Happened? For about seven in 10 major rules issued without public input over the past 12 years, federal agencies invoked a legal shortcut called the "good cause" exception, according to a report released Sept. 4 by the Government Accountability Office (GAO), the nonpartisan congressional watchdog. []( ngr-a278ec8c-a969-4b30-94cc-ef8f4a0eac4f) Under a law called the Administrative Procedure Act (APA), agencies normally must propose a rule, accept public comments, and then issue a final version. The good cause exception lets agencies skip that process when they judge it impractical, unnecessary, or against the public interest. For example, during a natural disaster or public health emergency. The GAO reviewed every major rule issued through that shortcut between Jan. 20, 2013, and Jan. 20, 2025, covering both interim final rules and direct final rules. Why Does it Matter to Me? When agencies bypass the standard comment process, businesses, workers, and ordinary citizens lose their formal chance to weigh in before a rule takes effect. That affects anyone regulated by federal rules, which covers industries from health care and banking to farming and energy. The GAO report also found that one-third of these expedited major rules lacked any documented analysis of their economic effects. That means the public and policymakers often had no clear picture of what a rule would cost or save before it went into force. A few other findings worth knowing: Agencies still asked for public comments on 99 percent of interim final rules, but those comment periods came after the rule was already in effect, limiting how much feedback could change the rule's core terms. During the COVID-19 pandemic in 2020 and 2021, agencies rushed out numerous rules without the standard process, with many citing good cause. Outside of crisis years, agencies still issued between two and 10 major expedited rules per year. Both Sides, Now The GAO report does not take a political side, and the source material does not include on-record statements from Republicans, Democrats, or the White House responding to its findings. The tension the report describes is procedural: supporters of the good cause exception argue it is a necessary safety valve that lets government respond quickly when waiting for public comment would cause real harm. Critics argue the data (a large share of expedited major rules invoking the exception across 12 years and multiple administrations) suggests the shortcut has become routine rather than reserved for genuine emergencies. Congress wrote the APA and retains the power to tighten or clarify when the good cause exception may be used. The report does not recommend specific legislation, but it documents the pattern for lawmakers to consider. What Happens Next? The GAO released its findings to Congress, which can hold hearings, request agency responses, or draft legislation to narrow when the good cause exception applies. No hearing or bill has been announced in response to this report. Agencies themselves could also tighten their own internal standards for invoking the exception, though the report does not record any agency commitments to do so. --- Spot something wrong? Report an issue with this article
Millions of immigrants living in the United States without legal entry could be held in federal custody indefinitely, with no right to ask a judge for...
American goods crossing into Canada and Canadian goods heading south now face a new layer of tariffs and trade friction, following a series of moves by the...
The United States needs hundreds of thousands of new welders, shipbuilders, and skilled tradespeople to keep its military supplied, and federal officials...
Nearly $300 billion in potential federal savings is sitting on a shelf in Washington, waiting for Congress to act. A May 12 report from the Government...
Foreign investors owned about 47.2 million acres of U.S. farmland as of 2024, roughly one out of every 28 acres of privately held agricultural land in the...
When a tornado levels a neighborhood or a hurricane floods a city, the Federal Emergency Management Agency (FEMA) is usually the backstop. But a shift is...
The U.S. teen birth rate dropped to 12.6 births per 1,000 females ages 15 to 19 in 2024, a 3.8 percent decline from the year before, according to a...
Millions of Americans living in U.S. territories can open the new federally backed children's savings accounts created by the One Big Beautiful Bill Act,...
American colleges that accept federal student aid money could be barred from supporting boycotts of Israel under a bill the House passed Thursday. The...