What Happened?

If your city, county, or local nonprofit depends on federal money for emergency planning, the agency that hands it out has not been clear about how it decides who gets it. The Federal Emergency Management Agency (FEMA) runs 13 preparedness grant programs totaling $2.9 billion for fiscal year 2026, and the Government Accountability Office (GAO) says that lack of openness is a problem, according to a Legis1 review of its report on grant transparency and communication published Nov. 12. ​

The grants pay state and local governments, nonprofits, and other groups to prevent, prepare for, and respond to terrorism and disasters. They fund training, exercises, equipment, planning and communications for threats such as mass shootings and attacks on transit systems or ports.

GAO's earlier reviews found the same kinds of gaps:

  • Transit security: In July 2023, GAO found FEMA's 2021 transit security grants notice inaccurately described how applications would be scored.
  • Port security: In September 2025, GAO found the port security grants announcement did not disclose all evaluation criteria or explain how they were weighted.
  • Priority areas: In January 2024, GAO reported FEMA did not notify stakeholders before it put the National Priority Areas in place.
  • Risk models: GAO found FEMA's risk assessment model did not consistently explain how risk factors were weighted or why calculations changed year to year.

Why Does it Matter to Me?

If a grant application is scored by rules the applicant cannot see, a community may not know why it won or lost money for its emergency response. GAO found FEMA did not consistently award transit security funding to applicants with the top scores.

Recipients count on the money to keep up emergency gear, including replacing expired personal protective equipment. GAO warned that funding disruptions and a lack of transparency threaten FEMA's ability to send limited money to the communities where it could reduce the greatest risks.

In 2025, the Department of Homeland Security (DHS), which includes FEMA, terminated grants and paused funding, delaying payments to recipients.

Both Sides, Now

GAO's position is that FEMA's openness, communication, and risk methods fall short. It said FEMA's outreach did not effectively gather stakeholder feedback.

In April 2025, a U.S. district court ordered FEMA to stop delaying payments while a lawsuit continued.

DHS also attached conditions to grant awards, including requirements that recipients cooperate with federal immigration enforcement. A federal district court barred DHS from enforcing the 2025 conditions, but the department attached similar conditions to later awards. That litigation was still ongoing as of November.

What Happens Next?

GAO listed four open recommendations FEMA could act on:

  • Disclose criteria: Fully reveal the standards used to evaluate applications.
  • Match priorities: Align evaluations with the agency's funding priorities.
  • Count threats: Account for relevant threats in certain grant risk models.
  • Learn lessons: Use lessons from earlier challenges before taking future grant actions.

All four recommendations remain open.

---

AllCiv makes it easy to stay politically informed and involved.

---

Spot something wrong? Report an issue with this article