What Happened?

If you send a comment on a federal land rule and you are not a U.S. citizen, a Senate bill would require the federal land agency to set your comment aside. The American Voices in Federal Lands Act was reported out of the Senate Energy and Natural Resources Committee with an amendment on Nov. 12, according to a Legis1 review of the bill's history. ​

The agency is the Bureau of Land Management (BLM). The committee's version would change the original bill in four ways:

  • Technology mandate: BLM would have to use the best available technology to deter ineligible people and groups, replacing a specific CAPTCHA requirement, a test that tells computers from humans, to block AI bots.
  • Who qualifies: Eligible commenters include U.S.-born and naturalized citizens, plus legal entities formed under state, territorial or District of Columbia law and based in the U.S.
  • No workaround: An ineligible person or group cannot qualify by sending comments through an American representative or agent.
  • Mail comments: The changes do not affect comments sent by mail.

Why Does it Matter to Me?

If your group weighs in on how public lands are managed, the bill would decide whether your comment counts. Environmental organizations, businesses and advocacy groups take part in these decisions, according to Legis1, and the bill would matter most to those that represent international interests or noncitizen communities.

The bill covers rulemaking, the process in which an agency writes a rule and collects public comments first. Sen. John Barrasso (R-WY) introduced it July 10, 2025.

Both Sides, Now

Supporters say the bill keeps foreign influence and automated submissions out of land decisions. Barrasso's announcement described it as a way to stop foreign individuals and AI bots from influencing federal energy and public lands policy. The Wyoming Tribune Eagle and K2 Radio described the bill's goals in similar terms.

Critics of citizenship limits argue the bill would shut out expertise and affected perspectives, especially those of Tribal entities and other noncitizens. As an example of public input shaping a land rule, the Federal Register shows that BLM's May 9, 2024, final rule on conservation and landscape health was updated in response to comments and consultation, including provisions on Tribal co-stewardship.

A Senate subcommittee on public lands examined the bill at a hearing. All seven cosponsors are Republicans, including Sen. Mike Crapo (R-ID) and Sen. Jim Risch (R-ID). No Democratic or independent senators have signed on.

What Happens Next?

The full Senate must decide whether to take up the bill, and the House would then have to pass it before the president could sign it. It sits on the Senate's calendar of bills awaiting floor action, which makes it eligible for a vote.

If senators want to change the citizenship limits or the technology requirement, they could seek amendments before a vote. As of now, no floor vote has been scheduled.

---

AllCiv makes it easy to stay politically informed and involved.

---

Spot something wrong? Report an issue with this article