What Happened?
When police investigate a crime, they sometimes ask Google for a list of every device that was in a specific area at a specific time. These are called geofence warrants, and the Supreme Court ruled on June 29 that pulling that location data counts as a search under the Fourth Amendment, which protects Americans from unreasonable government searches. The case, Chatrie v. United States, did not end there, though. The Court sent the case back to a lower court without deciding whether the specific warrant used was actually valid.
A new report from the Congressional Research Service (CRS), the nonpartisan agency that researches legal and policy questions for Congress, examined whether these reverse warrants, including a related tool called keyword warrants, where police ask for data on everyone who searched a specific term, hold up under the Constitution.
Why Does it Matter to Me?
If you carry a smartphone, your location history may be stored by companies like Google, and law enforcement can request it. Google reported receiving roughly 9,000 geofence requests in 2019 alone, and by 2021 those requests made up more than 25 percent of all warrants Google received in the United States. The company also processes about 400 reverse-keyword warrants per year.
That means your device could appear in a criminal investigation simply because you were near a crime scene or searched a particular term, even if you had nothing to do with the offense.
Both Sides, Now
The core legal debate is whether these tools give police too much power or are a necessary part of modern investigations. In the Chatrie case, seven judges found that accessing geofence data is a Fourth Amendment search, but five of those judges said the warrant used lacked the required probable cause. Only one judge, Judge Roger Gregory, said the evidence should have been thrown out. The other six judges said it could stay in under the "good-faith exception," a legal rule that allows evidence collected under a flawed warrant if officers reasonably believed it was valid.
Congress has taken notice. Then-House Judiciary Committee Chairman Rep. Jim Jordan (R-OH) sent a 2023 letter to the Attorney General asking about geofence warrants used in January 6 investigations. Sen. Alex Padilla (D-CA) wrote to Google in 2022 urging the company to limit location data collection, citing concerns about abortion-related investigations. The CRS report notes that the constitutional status of keyword-search warrants remains unsettled because no federal appeals court has yet ruled on whether obtaining that data is a search at all.
What Happens Next?
The Fourth Circuit court must now decide whether the warrant in the Chatrie case met the Constitution's probable-cause and particularity requirements, meaning police must show evidence of a crime and describe specifically what they are looking for. That ruling could set a national precedent for how these warrants are used.
In the meantime, states are moving on their own. Utah now requires a search warrant for geofence data and restricts keyword warrants. Washington bars private companies from setting up geofences around health care facilities. Similar measures were proposed in Vermont, New York, Missouri, Delaware, and California. Google announced in 2023 it would shorten the default storage period for location history from 18 months to three months and move that data from its own servers to users' devices.
Congress could also act, but no federal legislation is currently scheduled for a vote.
---
This article was generated by AI pulling from data. Each article is edited by an editor for accuracy and clarity.
---
Spot something wrong? Report an issue with this article