What happened?
Two fathers testified before Congress last week that their daughters were left permanently disabled after crashes involving undocumented immigrants, putting a human face on a national debate over whether cities and states should be required to help federal agents enforce immigration law.
The House Judiciary Subcommittee on Immigration Integrity, Security, and Enforcement held a Sept. 1 hearing titled "Sanctuary Policies, Tragic Consequences." The session focused on so-called sanctuary policies, rules adopted by some states and localities that limit how much local police and jails cooperate with federal immigration authorities. The Congressional Research Service (CRS), Congress's nonpartisan research arm, counted 13 states and 225 localities with such policies as of January 2025, though it cautioned that no agreed-upon legal definition exists and the count is imprecise.
The hearing zeroed in on policies in California, Colorado, and Maryland.
Why Does it Matter to Me?
If you live in a jurisdiction with these policies, this debate could change how your local police department operates and whether it shares information with federal Immigration and Customs Enforcement (ICE).
Under a bill that has already cleared the House Judiciary Committee, H.R. 7640, the Shut Down Sanctuary Policies Act, localities that refuse to cooperate with ICE could lose certain federal law enforcement grants. The bill would also let crime victims sue jurisdictions that declined to honor an immigration detainer, which is a federal request to hold someone in custody for possible deportation.
Supporters of sanctuary policies argue that when local police stay out of immigration enforcement, immigrants are more willing to report crimes and cooperate with investigations, which can benefit everyone in a neighborhood.
Both sides, now
Republicans on the subcommittee argued that local governments must cooperate with ICE detainers and information requests. Subcommittee Chair Tom McClintock (R-CA), who introduced H.R. 7640, said the bill would override local restrictions on cooperation with federal immigration authorities, protect officers who work with federal agents, redirect grant money away from noncompliant jurisdictions, and create a legal path for victims in certain cases.
Jeffrey Gahler, the sheriff of Harford County, Maryland, testified that Maryland's Community Trust Act restricts cooperation with ICE and could require jails to release people the federal government wants held. Gahler is the lead plaintiff among 17 Maryland sheriffs challenging that state law in federal court.
Ranking Member Pramila Jayapal (D-WA) argued that pulling local officers into federal immigration work pulls them away from local crime. She said it can also make immigrant communities less willing to call police or report crimes.
David Bier, director of immigration studies at the Cato Institute, testified that academic research does not show that limits on local participation in immigration enforcement increase crime. His written testimony cited 12 studies he said found no such connection. Bier also argued that federal enforcement resources should focus on people who pose public-safety threats.
The CRS has noted that jurisdictions adopt these policies for a range of reasons, including concerns about legal liability from holding people on detainers, limited local budgets, family separation, and the removal of immigrants with minor or no criminal records.
What happens next?
H.R. 7640 has passed the House Judiciary Committee by a 22-11 vote and is on the calendar for a full House floor vote, but no vote date has been scheduled. The bill would still need to pass the full House and the Senate, and be signed by the president, before it becomes law.
Litigation is also moving on a parallel track. The 17 Maryland sheriffs, including Gahler, are challenging Maryland's Community Trust Act in federal court. The Justice Department has filed a separate federal lawsuit against the same law. A prior Justice Department lawsuit against four New Jersey cities was dismissed in June on procedural grounds, without a ruling on whether the cities' policies were legal.
The hearing record remained open after Sept. 1 for lawmakers to submit additional materials.
---
This article was generated by AI pulling from data. Each article is edited by an editor for accuracy and clarity.
---
Spot something wrong? Report an issue with this article