What Happened?
If you are a noncitizen accused of voting in a federal election, a Florida judge has ruled that Congress had no power to make that a crime in one defendant's case. The noncitizen voting ruling came Oct. 1 in United States v. Cox, according to a Legis1 review of a report from the Congressional Research Service (CRS), Congress's in-house research arm.
Congress passed the ban in 1996. The judge, sitting in the federal court for the Southern District of Florida, gave these reasons, as CRS describes them:
- State power: States hold the authority to set voter qualifications, including citizenship.
- Earlier ruling: The Supreme Court's *Oregon v. Mitchell* decision did not control, because the justices agreed on the outcome without a majority rationale.
- Immigration power: Congress's immigration authority did not support the ban, partly because it exempts certain nonfederal elections.
- Election rules: The Constitution's Elections Clause covers how elections are run, not who may vote.
Why Does it Matter to Me?
The ruling covers only the defendant in that case, and the ban remains federal law. It does not change who may vote in your state, because states set those rules.
The Trump administration's Department of Justice (DOJ) is still bringing cases. On Nov. 2, DOJ announced charges against 63 individuals across multiple states for election-related offenses, including alleged violations of the noncitizen voting ban. If higher courts side with the Florida judge, charges like those could be challenged.
Both Sides, Now
Opponents of the ban argue that noncitizen voting is rare, so a broad federal crime is unnecessary. The Brennan Center for Justice's May 2017 analysis, based on a survey of local election officials about the 2016 election, reported only a very small number of suspected noncitizen or fraudulent votes.
The government has appealed the Florida ruling, and DOJ cited the ban in an Oct. 15 complaint against California over ballots sent to people the government believed were likely noncitizens.
A district court denied its request for a temporary restraining order, a divided Ninth Circuit panel upheld that denial, and the Supreme Court denied an emergency injunction request with no noted dissent. DOJ dropped the case Nov. 6.
Other courts disagree. A magistrate judge in Wisconsin used similar reasoning to dismiss two criminal cases, while a Texas federal judge rejected reliance on *Cox* in a comparable challenge.
Congress wrote the law, so it holds the power to change it.
What Happens Next?
The U.S. Court of Appeals for the 11th Circuit is reviewing the appeal. If it upholds the ruling, similar noncitizen defendants prosecuted in that circuit could cite it to challenge federal charges.
Conflicting appeals court decisions could eventually send the question to the Supreme Court. Congress could also keep the law as is, repeal it and leave enforcement to states, or amend it to cover voting in violation of state eligibility rules, a change the judge suggested would raise "very different" constitutional questions.
---
AllCiv makes it easy to stay politically informed and involved.
---
Spot something wrong? Report an issue with this article