What Happened?

If you want to make or transfer a silencer, a short-barreled rifle or a short-barreled shotgun, the federal government stopped requiring approval and registration on Oct. 9. A federal court in the Northern District of Texas ruled Aug. 5 that those National Firearms Act rules go beyond Congress's powers, according to a Legis1 review of a report by the Congressional Research Service (CRS), Congress's research agency. ​

The Bureau of Alcohol, Tobacco, Firearms, and Explosives (ATF) acted under the Trump administration. Its director issued an open letter saying ATF will no longer require approval before people make or transfer those items, or "any other weapon[s]." ATF will also stop requiring them to be listed in the National Firearms Registration and Transfer Record.

The dispute traces to the "One Big Beautiful Bill Act," which became law July 4, 2025. It set a tax rate of zero, effective Jan. 1, for making or transferring these firearms.

Why Does it Matter to Me?

If you own or want to buy one of these items, the rules that applied to you have changed. CRS says the law did not repeal the National Firearms Act, so these pieces remain:

  • Occupational tax: The special occupational tax remains.
  • Approval rules: The approval requirements remain.
  • Background checks: The checks remain.
  • Registration: The registration requirement remains.
  • Penalties: Criminal penalties for possessing an unregistered firearm remain.

ATF's guidance page says the court's injunction covers the plaintiffs and other specified persons. It calls the broader policy an exercise of enforcement discretion. The act stays in full effect for machineguns and destructive devices.

Both Sides, Now

The plaintiffs in *Silencer Shop Foundation v. ATF* were "a coalition of individuals, businesses, associations, and states." They argued the taxing power cannot support the rules once the tax is gone. The court agreed, writing that "without a tax that raises at least some revenue, Congress cannot enact a statute under its taxing power."

Supporters of keeping the rules argue that removing them could reduce oversight and make covered firearms, especially silencers, harder to track. They point to the City of Virginia Beach investigation, which says an employee killed 12 people and wounded five on May 31, 2019, and that the shooter obtained a suppressor.

The Trace found 153 federal cases in which a silencer was used in a crime from 1995 to 2005.

What Happens Next?

Congress holds the power to change the rules. CRS says it could add a dollar amount to the tax, identify a separate constitutional basis such as interstate commerce, or remove the registration requirements or the funding to enforce them. Any of those would require a new law.

CRS says invalidating the rules would likely leave the firearms regulated like others under the Gun Control Act. The court declined to address the plaintiffs' Second Amendment claim, so that question remains undecided.

---

AllCiv makes it easy to stay politically informed and involved.

---

Spot something wrong? Report an issue with this article