What Happened?
If your retirement savings sit in a 401(k) plan, the federal government has not yet told you or your employer how private equity, a type of investment in privately held companies, differs from the funds you own now.
The Government Accountability Office (GAO) said in a report released publicly last week that the Department of Labor (DOL) has issued no specific guidance on private equity, and GAO warned of oversight gaps.
According to a Legis1 review of the report, which GAO published Oct. 8, the gap affects plan sponsors, the employers who pick a plan's investment options, and participants, the workers who save in it.
Private equity has mostly been open to wealthy individuals and institutional investors, including pension funds. The asset class is expected to become more common in retirement plans.
GAO made three recommendations to DOL's Employee Benefits Security Administration:
- Collect data: Gather figures on how much 401(k) money is invested in private equity, including holdings buried inside other investment options.
- Guide sponsors: Explain to employers how private equity is defined, how its liquidity and valuation differ, and how it is regulated.
- Guide savers: Explain to participants how liquidity, valuation, and other factors affect their ability to compare investment options.
Why Does it Matter to Me?
Private equity can be harder to sell or turn into cash than a publicly traded stock, a trait called illiquidity. Consumer advocates told GAO that this needs explaining to savers.
GAO's review of research papers found no consensus on whether private equity beats publicly traded stocks. Some studies found it outperformed in the periods examined, though the size of the gains varied. Others found it fell behind once risks or fees, which can run higher than on public investments, were counted.
Plan sponsors and industry associations also told GAO that plan administrators need more education on how these investments are valued, compared with mutual funds. Plan sponsors have fiduciary responsibilities when choosing investment options. Participants must weigh the risks and benefits of what they are offered.
Both Sides, Now
GAO's position is that better data and guidance would help both sponsors and participants make informed choices about investments that work differently from traditional mutual funds. It found little is known about how much private equity 401(k) plans hold today.
DOL, according to GAO, neither agreed nor disagreed with the recommendations. Federal law authorizes DOL to issue regulations and other guidance to protect retirement security. GAO is the one asking for that guidance.
What Happens Next?
All three recommendations remain open, and the report sets no deadlines for carrying them out. DOL would have to act on them, and GAO said it will update the status of each after confirming what DOL has done.
---
AllCiv makes it easy to stay politically informed and involved.
---
Spot something wrong? Report an issue with this article