Nonpartisan civic infrastructure
AllCiv·Legis1
·

U.S. News

Nonpartisan, data-driven coverage · Sunday, November 22, 2026Nonpartisan, data-driven. 11/22/2026
Health

Surprise Medical Bill Dispute System Has Deep Structural Problems

Oct 12, 2026

What Happened? If you've ever gotten a large, unexpected bill from a doctor who wasn't in your insurance network, you know how jarring that can be. The Congressional Research Service (CRS) found deep structural problems in the federal dispute resolution system designed to protect patients from shock medical bills. ​ The No Surprises Act (NSA), passed as part of a broader federal spending law in 2021, created federal protections against surprise medical bills from out-of-network providers. At its center is an Independent Dispute Resolution (IDR) process, where a private arbitrator decides how much an insurer must pay an out-of-network provider. The IDR entity selects between each side's payment offer. Why Does it Matter to Me? What happens in arbitration affects what you pay out of pocket, because your cost-sharing is tied to the Qualifying Payment Amount (QPA), generally an insurer's 2019 median in-network rate for a service, adjusted for inflation. Any change that raises the QPA directly increases what patients pay for out-of-network care. Research found that some prices rose after arbitration, contrary to legislative expectations. Some physician practices also reported that health plans used the No Surprises Act to justify cutting or ending in-network contracts. Both Sides, Now Providers argue that insurers artificially suppress the QPA to tilt arbitration in their favor. Out-of-network providers or facilities prevailed in 85.7 percent of disputes from 2023 through 2025, according to a Congressional Research Service report. Opponents of the current framework point to serious operational breakdowns. On Feb. 24, 2022, a federal judge threw out the rule giving the QPA a central role in arbitration, finding it legally defective, according to the Association of American Medical Colleges. On Aug. 25, 2023, federal IDR operations were temporarily suspended after another court ruling, according to Norton Rose Fulbright. The Trump administration has extended enforcement discretion on QPA calculation methods, allowing insurers to keep using older approaches beyond their originally intended expiration date. Congress has not passed new legislation to address the backlog or the QPA dispute. What Happens Next? Federal agencies finalized a new IDR Operations rule on June 4, 2026, which took effect June 11. The rule cut the administrative fee from $115 to $15 per party per dispute, capped bundled billing line items at 50 per dispute, and required insurers to disclose the QPA during negotiations. Legis1 says that even these changes may not resolve the underlying tension over the qualifying payment amount. Will the arbitration system deliver balanced results for patients and providers, or will the fight over the QPA keep driving costs and court battles? --- AllCiv makes it easy to stay politically informed and involved. --- Spot something wrong? Report an issue with this article

More from U.S. News

Law Enforcement

Court Strikes Down Parts of Federal Horse Soring Rule

Oct 12, 2026

Federal enforcement against horse soring, the deliberate infliction of pain to produce an exaggerated high-stepping gait, is tied up in litigation and...

Health

Radiation Victims' Compensation Program Set to Expire in 2027

Oct 12, 2026

Americans sickened by atomic weapons testing and nuclear weapons production could lose access to federal compensation in just over a year. The Radiation...

Politics

Pending Bills on Right Whales, Mining, College Aid, and Socialism

Oct 12, 2026

Lobster and crab fishermen in New England could get until 2035, instead of 2028, before facing new federal rules to protect endangered right whales. The...

Education

Congress to Examine Proposed $1,700 School Choice Tax Credit

Oct 12, 2026

Starting in 2027, eligible taxpayers could claim a federal tax credit of up to $1,700 for qualifying contributions. The U.S. Department of the Treasury and...

Elections

Trump-Linked Super PAC Pours $154M Into Senate, House Races

Oct 12, 2026

A political group with ties to President Donald Trump has poured more than $154 million into U.S. Senate and House races this election cycle, targeting...

Health

Congress Finds Employers Now Drive Most Health Savings Account Funding

Oct 12, 2026

If you have a health savings account, there's a good chance your employer is the one putting most of the money in, according to the Congressional Research...

Elections

Federal Election Changes Face Court Blocks and Unresolved Questions

Oct 12, 2026

How your state runs elections, who can register, how ballots are mailed, and what voting machines must meet, is under pressure from a series of federal...

Health

Watchdog Flags Safety Concerns Over Veterans' Health Records System

Oct 12, 2026

A Government Accountability Office (GAO) review found that 58 of 71 selected VA staff users said the system had increased or greatly increased patient...

Elections

Congress Could Ban or Require Ranked-Choice Voting Nationwide

Oct 12, 2026

How you vote in federal elections could soon be decided by Congress. The Congressional Research Service (CRS) released a report on ranked-choice voting...